The golden compass, a fantasy film starring nicole kidman that is scheduled to be released into theaters on 7 december 2007, has been drawing fire from concerned christians. The film, now open nationwide, is based on his dark materials, a trilogy of books by english author philip pullman, a selfproclaimed atheist. Its a bunch of characters going through actions who dont seem to have any motivation or reason for what they are doing and the only reason why they are doing what they are doing is because a script tells them to. The golden compass is a 2007 fantasy adventure film based on northern lights, the first novel in philip pullmans trilogy his dark materials. The movie version of philip pullmans golden compass creates a luminous. The following post contains spoilers for the golden compass and hbos his dark materials show. Author of his dark materials trilogy included on american library associations.
I surmise that the poster is an american, given that the question refers to the american title of the book known in its country of origin as northern lights. But now some of the authors fans may think the film adaptations not. It seems as if most of the challenges and controversy flared up in 2007 and 2008 when the movie came out, not in 1995 when the book was published. I wouldnt say religious power is nothing compared to the power of a king, but i would say religious power can be used as another form of political power, and often is. Unfortunately for new line, the golden compass is also a deceptively tricky book, using the trappings of childrens fantasy to deliver an antichristian allegory in the same way c. The golden compass religious controversy aside, this lavish adaptation of philip pullmans beloved book is its own kind of hell. The golden compass is a darker, deeper fantasy epic than the rings trilogy, the chronicles of narnia or the potter films. Eternal salvation is more likely for abortionists and nunrapists than for anyone who dares buy a ticket for the golden compass, judging by the christian rights prerelease indignation over the. Ted baehr of the christian film and television commission calls the golden compass an atheists narnia knockoff, referring to the best selling books the chronicles of narnia by c. The golden compass is the first book of the dust series by philip pullman.
Besides hannah montana 3d, theres another movie event happening this weekend. From this we know that were not just dealing with the typical comingofage themes youd find in your average novel for tweens and teens. League launched against the film version of the golden compass. The religious controversy surrounding philip pullmans his. The religious controversy over the books passed me by until i went. But development of the golden compass was mired in controversy, including a boycott by religious groups, an odd choice of director, and its handwringing treatment of the books religious themes. The golden compass is based on the first book in the trilogy his dark materials, written by philip pullman.
Childrens writer philip pullman ranked second on us banned books list. I have not said anything about the controversy over the golden compass, because the issue has seemed too simple and clear cut to warrant comment. In 2007, the catholic league campaigned against the golden compass, declaring. A warning about a new film for december, 2007, titled the golden compass. They live at oxford universitys jordan college, among scholars and other brainytypes. The film the golden compass is a controversy among. One advantage religion has over politics is its direct access to an emotional hold over its professers, which gives it more buttons to push where. But take a look at what appeared in this weeks american libraries direct. In the golden compass, readers meet for the first time 11yearold lyra belacqua, a precocious orphan growing up within the precincts of jordan college in oxford, england. The golden compass controversy page 9 science fiction.
The golden compass is the first installment of pullmans his dark materials trilogy, three books that set out to rewrite john miltons epic 17th century poem paradise lost. Pullman defiant over us protests against northern lights books. Craig likened the controversy surrounding the golden compass to. The project was announced in february 2002, but difficulties over the script and the selection of a director caused. How the other characters relate to lyra, which evolves over the course of. Furthermore, the first published book from narnia begins with a young girl hiding in a wardrobe, as does the first his dark materials book. Golden compass has already stirred some controversy among religious groups which, of course, have not seen it, due to the antiinstitutional religious bent of the book, but the irony is that purists of pullmans books might complain that the movie went too far in the other direction in defusing the overtly catholic contents, turning the. The golden compass accused of anticatholic bias several torontoarea catholic school boards in ontario have removed philip. Banzai onetime mod, but on the road to recovery contributor. The lackluster opening of the controversial movie the golden compass has some media outlets reporting that a christianorganized boycott of the film seems to be working. It springs from the same british world of quasiphilosophical magic, but creates more complex villains and poses more intriguing. The golden compass is a dumbeddown picturebook version of the novel with simple characterizations of the people in the novel. Childrens writer philip pullman ranked second on us banned books list this article is more than 10 years old author of his dark materials trilogy included on american library associations 2008. The film is based on northern lights released in the u.
Childrens writer philip pullman ranked second on us. A new 180 million dollar movie based on the first book of philip pullmans best selling trilogy, his dark materials, has sparked furious controversy in the christian world. After reading an article from abc news, it became clear that the golden compass was challenged because people felt it was spreading an antireligious or proatheist message. The golden compass is a blatant attack on christianity. The catholic league has called for a boycott of the golden compass. His dark materials, and northern lights is one of my favourite books ever. With the golden compass philip pullman garnered every accolade under the sun. Pullmans main character in the books, a girl named lyra, battles the dark. Philip pullmans incendiary his dark materials trilogy ignited. With nicole kidman, daniel craig, dakota blue richards, ben walker. The golden compass controversy creative writing forums. Golden compass has drawn a lot of flak from church groups over the killinggod thing, incidentally, and i can only presume that, as usual, most of the people protesting havent actually read the. The project was announced in february 2002, but difficulties over.
Pullmans childrens novel, which is sold as the golden compass in the us, was the fourth most challenged book in 2007, according to the american library association, which received 420 formally. Curious to see what the hubbub is, or are you a fan of the golden compass fantasy trilogy. So what does everyone think about the religious controversy over the movie the golden compass. Meet our protagonist, lyra, and her daemon pantalaimon the shapeshifting animal that is her soul, or pan for short. The film bombed when it finally hit theaters in 2007so badly, in fact, that its been cited as one of the main reasons new line went under. The film the golden compass is a controversy among christianstruth. Theres a certain kind of person, generally evangelical christian, that is very partial t. Childrens writer philip pullman ranked second on us banned. Northern lights titled the golden compass in north america and some other countries is a youngadult fantasy novel by philip pullman, published in 1995 by scholastic. Written and directed by chris weitz, it stars nicole kidman, dakota blue richards, daniel craig, sam elliott, eva green, and ian mckellen.
Critics lobbed around such superlatives as elegant, aweinspiring, grand, and. The young filmmaker had fatefully accepted the challenge of adapting philip pullmans the golden compass, and since the north pole was a crucial locale in. The religious controversy surrounding philip pullmans his dark. Tranter suggests the controversy over the golden compass. Before the hbo show, we revisit the infamous controversy around philip pullmans proudly atheist the golden compass. It is incredibly wellwritten and a real treat for the imagination. Octavo, jacket illustrated by eric rohmann, charcoal and black. Kidman, who plays a glamorous villain with a soul of ice, rejects the claim that the movie. Pullman defiant over us protests against northern lights. The first book really has the least controversy in it. Why was the golden compass book banned philip pullmans. Pullmans childrens novel, which is sold as the golden compass in the us.
New line cinema will release the golden compass, based on the first book in a trilogy of edgy childrens novels written by the. Some christians thought philip pullmans novel was blasphemous. The young filmmaker had fatefully accepted the challenge of adapting philip pullmans the golden compass, and since the north pole was a crucial locale in the book, weitz thought tapping out the. The golden compass and anticatholic bias litwin books. The controversy now has the studio spinning the golden compass as a celebration of love and friendship.
Northern lights in philip pullmans his dark materials trilogy, the golden compass. Over the summer, the catholic league started hearing about an upcoming film called the golden compass. The golden compass is an honorable work and especially impressive, given the far smaller, more intimate scale of his last film as a director with his brother, paul, about a boy. Furor over a new film titled the golden compasstruth. Donate to help vulnerable communities cope with covid19 donate. The golden compass 2 release date, cast, trailer premiere. After reading john miltons paradise lost, a retelling of genesis 3, pullman came to believe that the teachings of scripture were contrary to the way things ought to. Buy a cheap copy of the subtle knife book by philip pullman. In order to fulfill the requirements of the bookmovie comparison barc task, christina has written her thoughts on the film the golden compass and the. Why was the golden compass book banned philip pullmans his. Though we were not familiar with the trilogy, we heard whispers in the blogosphere that the books were decidedly anticatholic.
The books are so spiritual and they have got so much to say about our human. In a parallel universe, young lyra belacqua journeys to the far. The film was to be based on the first book of a trilogy called his dark materials written by british childrens author philip pullman. The fantasy adventure film, the golden compass, elicited indignant protest and calls for a worldwide boycott from the catholic league for religious and civil rights. Critics slam golden compass movie for castrating anti. Paradise lost, book 7, lines 224229 despite the confusion with the other common meaning of compass the navigational instrument the golden compass became the title of the american edition of northern lights the book features an alethiometer, a rare truthtelling device that one might describe as a golden compass plot northern lights or the golden compass. Philip pullmans his dark materials series was number 8 on the top 100 bannedchallenged books list for 20002009. Nailbiting, violent fantasy has elements of mystery. You dont have to be a kiddie lit maven to have heard about the tempest over fridays theatrical release of the golden compass. Boycott credited for golden compass lackluster opening. It quickly becomes clear that lyras oxford is not precisely like our own nor is her world.
534 278 509 1440 224 932 687 403 221 671 638 770 731 701 626 44 1047 772 597 1135 1494 89 593 1443 285 952 364 1385 249 1055 1215 279 952 1173 896 427 1284 494